dumb question.... am I "secular" or not?
Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Des Plaines,IL
Posts: 187
So we agree on the above.
BUT the definition of ATHEISM isn't lack of belief in ANYTHING, it's the lack of belief in a DEITY ONLY. Do you see how you're expanding the definition to fit your own beliefs? Atheists believe in many things. Just not deities. I can't think of anything I worship. I'm an atheist.
I don't think that I am expanding the definition at all. I am merely making a distinction between believing and worshipping. People can believe in the existence of a God and choose not to worship that God, such as deists do. Similarly, some people can engage in self-worship while at the same time deny that they are doing anything of the sort. They have become gods, de facto, yet they deny the existence of any gods. I am not saying that you are worshipping yourself. I am just saying that it is possible for one to do so and deny it.
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 590
I don't think that I am expanding the definition at all. I am merely making a distinction between believing and worshipping. People can believe in the existence of a God and choose not to worship that God, such as deists do. Similarly, some people can engage in self-worship while at the same time deny that they are doing anything of the sort. They have become gods, de facto, yet they deny the existence of any gods. I am not saying that you are worshipping yourself. I am just saying that it is possible for one to do so and deny it.[/QUOTE]
Hi ccirider, Hmmm, I'm wondering if you think most atheists worship themselves because they don't believe in a deity. That is an interesting concept that never ever even occurred to me. Is that what you mean? If so, I can only speak for myself of course, but I feel like I just AM. I don't feel like I worship anything at all. The way I look at it is that instead of concentrating on "something up there" I concentrate on people helping people. How we got here or where we are going (if anywhere) after we die are both unknowns. If I need help with something I focus on other people for my inspiration/help. That sort of thing. People helping people rather than a HP helping.
KariSue
Hi ccirider, Hmmm, I'm wondering if you think most atheists worship themselves because they don't believe in a deity. That is an interesting concept that never ever even occurred to me. Is that what you mean? If so, I can only speak for myself of course, but I feel like I just AM. I don't feel like I worship anything at all. The way I look at it is that instead of concentrating on "something up there" I concentrate on people helping people. How we got here or where we are going (if anywhere) after we die are both unknowns. If I need help with something I focus on other people for my inspiration/help. That sort of thing. People helping people rather than a HP helping.
KariSue
Member
Join Date: Nov 2007
Location: Des Plaines,IL
Posts: 187
Originally Posted by ccirider
I don't think that I am expanding the definition at all. I am merely making a distinction between believing and worshipping. People can believe in the existence of a God and choose not to worship that God, such as deists do. Similarly, some people can engage in self-worship while at the same time deny that they are doing anything of the sort. They have become gods, de facto, yet they deny the existence of any gods. I am not saying that you are worshipping yourself. I am just saying that it is possible for one to do so and deny it.
Originally Posted by KariSue
Hi ccirider, Hmmm, I'm wondering if you think most atheists worship themselves because they don't believe in a deity. That is an interesting concept that never ever even occurred to me. Is that what you mean?
43. Do you not see the one who has taken his own passion (or impulse) as his god? Are you going to be a guardian (disposer of his affairs) for him? (Surah 25, Verse 43)
Anything can be an object of worship, so why can't someone's passion be that object of worship? Does not an addict, in the latter stages of his addiction, treat his passion like an object of worship? He obsesses over it, and compulsively acts it out as if he is performing a daily ritual. I would say that is a form of worship, just like idol worship or hero worship is a form of worship.
The point I was making is that believing and worshipping are two different things. As I said, one can believe in the existence of a god and choose not to worship that god, as deists do. Similarly, an atheist addict can worship his passion, while at the same time deny that he is doing so. Most addicts deny that they are addicts, anyway, so what is another denial among many? I am not here to bash atheist addicts, since many theist addicts are in denial that they are worshipping their passion, also. As a matter of fact, I am not here to bash addicts, theists or atheists, since I once had a drinking and drugging problem myself.
Islam worked for me to get sober, but it's not everybody. As the last part of that verse said, "Are you going to be a guardian (disposer of his affairs) for him?" I am not brothers keeper, nor am I a babysitter/guardian over him. I can't fix people or make them face their problems. Actions have consequences and people need to suffer the consequences of their own actions without me enabling them.
Member
Join Date: Jan 2008
Location: bangalore,karnataka
Posts: 2
What are the qualifications to being a christian could you please clarify because i never knew till today there was a certificate attached to it. Thought it was all about living a life as a good human being and making the world a better place to live in.would love to hear your views on it.
What are the qualifications to being a christian could you please clarify because i never knew till today there was a certificate attached to it. Thought it was all about living a life as a good human being and making the world a better place to live in.would love to hear your views on it.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)