Movie: "Smashed" Really Worth a Watch
Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 8,642
Spoiler Alert....don't read if you haven't watched.....I watched 'Smashed' last night. I thought it was very well done, but I was disappointed in the omission of parts of the young woman's withdrawal. It is not possible to drink that huge amount of alcohol and not experience WDs. A massive hangover doesn't show the complete picture IMHO....However, most parts of the movie were spot on....very realistic. The end left me wondering if she would indeed "go back" or not. If you've seen the movie, what do you think?
Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: pa
Posts: 297
Spoiler Alert....don't read if you haven't watched.....I watched 'Smashed' last night. I thought it was very well done, but I was disappointed in the omission of parts of the young woman's withdrawal. It is not possible to drink that huge amount of alcohol and not experience WDs. A massive hangover doesn't show the complete picture IMHO....However, most parts of the movie were spot on....very realistic. The end left me wondering if she would indeed "go back" or not. If you've seen the movie, what do you think?
as far as the end, i think they leave it pretty open-ended to show that one year of sobriety doesn't automatically mean someone is cured. It could go either way.
Member
Join Date: Feb 2012
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 8,642
Very interesting, avocado. I just assumed she/they were heavy daily drinkers . I didn't get from the movie that she was an 'occasional' binge drinker, but I could be wrong. My own drinking was daily( at the end). I never had binges like the character in the movie, but I did have moderately severe ( if there is such a thing ) withdrawals....spent 3 days in a medical detox. Thanks for your input about binges and WDs....that never occurred to me.
I agree with you about the ending. And it's true that one year of sobriety doesn't automatically mean one is cured. I liked the metaphor of her husband asking for "one last game"...... Not unlike "one last drink."
I agree with you about the ending. And it's true that one year of sobriety doesn't automatically mean one is cured. I liked the metaphor of her husband asking for "one last game"...... Not unlike "one last drink."
Member
Join Date: Dec 2008
Location: pa
Posts: 297
yeah, i saw the characters in the film as living the kind of lifestyle i was living - basically social drinkers who get too carried away and wind up on binges, but then must straighten themselves out to some degree to never become as physically addicted as others. that's what makes me think she was more like i was. i would drink heavily for maybe a week, then take a week off or with only moderate drinking, maybe a six pack a night, then maybe a few days where my body had enough so i stopped for a week, then I'd feel good and go on another drug and alcohol binge. so, i never really got to the point where i'd be suffering major withdrawals, but the danger with me was that when i'd binge i'd lose total control of my behavior like she did and do really stupid, dangerous stuff.
when i finally quit this last time (i had basically done half-assed attempts at quitting on almost a monthly basis all of last year and for years before i would often half-assedly 'quit'), my body was used to stopping for a week or so at a time, then having anxiety and trouble sleeping and mood swings, so it never got worse than that this time. I suppose I'm lucky that I never developed a serious physical dependency, but this probably is a result of several years of constant dealing with this cyclic struggle of binging, then cutting down or stopping because of the psychological/financial/legal damage done, then feeling better about myself and being a happy guy again who thought he could just go have fun and have a few drinks. late 2011 and all of last year it just started becoming worse and worse the things that would happen i finally realized were going to cause me to wind up in jail or dead, so i finally had to stop. For me, it's not so much cravings for alcohol that I have to watch out for, it's ever slipping back into that mode of thinking that I can be the guy who can drink in moderation just to have fun. The scary thing is I probably could do that, for a while, but eventually it just gets worse and worse.
so anyway, maybe i was projecting my own experiences on to the movie, but it makes a lot of sense from that perspective. I could relate to the main character 100%. I could have written that film, to be honest.
when i finally quit this last time (i had basically done half-assed attempts at quitting on almost a monthly basis all of last year and for years before i would often half-assedly 'quit'), my body was used to stopping for a week or so at a time, then having anxiety and trouble sleeping and mood swings, so it never got worse than that this time. I suppose I'm lucky that I never developed a serious physical dependency, but this probably is a result of several years of constant dealing with this cyclic struggle of binging, then cutting down or stopping because of the psychological/financial/legal damage done, then feeling better about myself and being a happy guy again who thought he could just go have fun and have a few drinks. late 2011 and all of last year it just started becoming worse and worse the things that would happen i finally realized were going to cause me to wind up in jail or dead, so i finally had to stop. For me, it's not so much cravings for alcohol that I have to watch out for, it's ever slipping back into that mode of thinking that I can be the guy who can drink in moderation just to have fun. The scary thing is I probably could do that, for a while, but eventually it just gets worse and worse.
so anyway, maybe i was projecting my own experiences on to the movie, but it makes a lot of sense from that perspective. I could relate to the main character 100%. I could have written that film, to be honest.
You should consider posting this here: Recovery, Addiction, and Alcoholism in the News, Movies, and Pop Culture - SoberRecovery : Alcoholism Drug Addiction Help and Information
If anyone wants to watch it free..... here it is in great quality. Hope the link is right.
Smashed.2012.LIMITED.BDRip.XviD-GECKOS.avi | PutLocker
Smashed.2012.LIMITED.BDRip.XviD-GECKOS.avi | PutLocker
New and learning
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Colorado
Posts: 85
Our weekly independent paper ran a review and I want to see it. I have an all day travel on sunday so I'll look at how to order off iTunes so I can keep busy. This will be up on my list! Thanks for the recommend!
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)