Thanks all. This really isn't bugging me, I just thought it was one of those things where SR would have interesting feedback -- and I was right.
I'm not going to speculate about either person. Oh, except C2 is an idiot, but I already knew that. I think it's interesting that I thought it was a big deal when I told C1 that I wasn't drinking (and I had reason to do so), but she apparently doesn't think of it that way.