View Single Post
Old 09-25-2017, 01:04 PM
  # 84 (permalink)  
Greenwood618
Guest
 
Join Date: Feb 2014
Posts: 170
Originally Posted by Algorithm View Post
Jeffrey knows very well that AVRT is not religious, and he says as much in his post, so I would wager that what actually concerns him is that AVRT does not exclude religiosity, unlike some other secular recovery homes he is accustomed to, where people often gather around and criticize the religiosity of mainstream recovery for most of the meetings. This is why he places devil in quotation marks, for example, as he does with Beast.

Of course, Beast is simply the name that AVRT gives to the addiction. It is no more a metaphor than 'triangle' is a metaphor for a geometric figure with three sides. Humans use language, and they name things in order to enable communication and complex thoughts. Were it otherwise, none of us would be able to communicate with each other over thousands of miles away via computer networks, as we are doing here, for example.

Addiction is not unique to secularists, however, and the religious-secular divide, as it pertains to addiction recovery, is entirely a consequence of having placed the adoption of a particular religious orientation as an obstacle to recovery for so long. Indeed, the sub-heading for the secular forum is "Alternatives to 12 Step Recovery", which perfectly reflects this reality.

AVRT, of course, is not an alternative to 12-Step recovery per se. Rather, it is an alternative to addiction, and it does not discriminate very much between secular and religious approaches. Its target is the Addictive Voice -- that comprehensive style of thinking that sustains addiction -- regardless of its source.



Perhaps, but AVRT would require no modifications if it really were Satan himself whispering sweet nothings into addicted people's ears. This is what concerns the ardent secularists.
Fascinating. So some people consistently blow their tops around here when AVRT comes up because it is not atheist enough for them? Had no idea.

"Secular" is a bit of a misnomer for AVRT discussions, in any case. Why not just have one called "AVRT Discussions?"

Because it is perfectly compatible with every religion, lack therof, and everything in between. There are a great many traditions on the the Latin American and Mediterranean Catholic churches of making a lifetime abstinence vow to a saint.

And while most religious leaders are poor addiction counselors, from what I have heard, the priests involved in such vows with their parishioners follow a coaching model that is basically AVRT's short program almost to the letter.

Certain key concepts here sure infuriate certain people, and looking back, that God isn't banned and that abstinence can be declared suddenly and permanently are the two biggies.
Greenwood618 is offline