Oh, I knew it wouldn't be a "worthwhile" read, but I was interested to hear about this person's reasoning that brought her to that conclusion. Heck, I read the Orange Papers, too. I like to know what the "haters" have to say. Sometimes SOME of the criticisms have SOME legitimacy. It is also helpful to know what is being said because you know there are potential newcomers to 12-Step programs that base their uninformed opinions on this sort of thing.