I don't have any experience in any of those particular treatment programs but I do have enough under my belt to know it doesn't matter what program you find him. If he doesn't want to go and doesn't want the treatment, it won't work. Like so many others you will be $2000 in the poor house and he will still continue to use. It's a sad truth..........you can lead an addict to recovery, but you can't make him recover. All said with love.