why is alcoholism called a disease?

Old 06-03-2004, 02:53 PM
  # 1 (permalink)  
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Txk, Texas
Posts: 5
why is alcoholism called a disease?

Alcoholism As a Disease
From Buddy T,
Your Guide to Alcoholism / Substance Abuse.
Sign up for my Newsletter

But It Doesn't Act Like a Disease!
One of the difficulties in recognizing alcoholism as a disease is it just plain doesn't seem like one. It doesn't look, sound, smell and it certainly doesn't act like a disease. To make matters worse, generally it denies it exists and resists treatment.

Alcoholism has been recognized for many years by professional medical organizations as a primary, chronic, progressive and sometimes fatal disease. The National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence offers a detailed and complete definition of alcoholism, but probably the most simple way to describe it is "a mental obsession that causes a physical compulsion to drink."

Mental obsession? Did you ever wake up in the morning with a song playing over and over in your head? It might have been a commercial jingle you heard on television, or a song from the radio, but it kept playing ... and playing and playing.

Mental Obsession
Remember what that was like? No matter what you did, that silly tune kept on playing. You could try to whistle or sing another song or turn on the radio and listen to another tune, but the one in your head just kept on playing. Think about it. There was something going on in your mind that you didn't put there and, no matter how hard you tried, couldn't get out!

That is an example of a simple mental obsession -- a thought process over which you have no control. Such is the nature of the disease of alcoholism. When the drinking "song" starts playing in the mind of an alcoholic, he is powerless. He didn't put the song there and the only way to get it to stop is to take another drink.

The problem is the alcoholic's mental obsession with alcohol is much more subtle than a song playing in his mind. In fact, he may not even know it's there. All he knows is he suddenly has an urge to take a drink -- a physical compulsion to drink.

Progressive Disease
Compounding the problem is the progressive nature of the disease. In its early stages, taking one or two drinks may be all it takes to get the "song" to stop. But soon it takes six or seven and later maybe ten or twelve. Somewhere down the road the only time the song stops is when he passes out.

The progression of the disease is so subtle and usually takes place over such an extended period of time, that even the alcoholic himself failed to notice the point at which he lost control -- and alcohol took over -- his life.

No wonder denial is an almost universal symptom of the disease. For those who have come to the realization that they do have a problem, help may be as close as the white pages of the telephone directory. But for those who need help and do not want it, intervention may be the only alternative.
confused one is offline  
Old 06-03-2004, 02:57 PM
  # 2 (permalink)  
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Txk, Texas
Posts: 5
In 1956 the American Medical Association decided that alcoholism is a disease, however more than 30 years later this is still debated in certain circles. Besides the medical opinion, there are many others (e.g., legal, sociological, religious) which derive from any number of social pressures. For example, the Supreme Court recently decided that the Veteran's Administration could consider alcoholism an individual choice rather than a disease. This decision, in many peoples' opinion, was made because of the financial implication related to "Service-connected Disability" payments rather than the merits, or lack thereof, of alcoholism as a disease. This in only one example of of the many biased opinions (including the medical one) on whether or not alcoholism is a disease.

What does support the concept of alcoholism as a disease? There is an abundance of information. Alcoholism is often compared to diabetes. Most people are able to eat carbohydrates and metabolize them without difficulty, however this is not the case with people who have diabetes mellitus. Many years ago, we had no idea why people with diabetes got into metabolic difficulty but now we know that it is because of an intrinsic lack of insulin and that this is genetically determined. There is a list of progressive symptoms related to diabetes: polyuria, polydipsia, weight loss, blurred vision, and nausea and vomiting are seen acutely. If the disease goes on untreated, then there is end organ failure disease goes on untreated, then there is end organ failure and patients with diabetes develop failure of their vision and kidneys as well as significant cardiovascular disease with heart attack and stroke. How does one treat this problem? The patient needs insulin and a very controlled lifestyle diet, exercise and very special attention to one's habits. This will at least slow down the progression of the disease.

The same concepts of "disease" apply to alcoholism, and the progression of the disease was defined by Jellinek and is shown on the attached was defined by Jellinek and is shown on the attached Jellinek chart. Alcoholism is a progressive and terminal disease if no intervention occurs. It is clear that alcoholism fits the definition of a disease, and there is additional supportive evidence of this concept based on recent research and literature.

Over the past few years investigators have invested a great deal of time, energy and finances into acquiring support for the idea that alcoholism may be a biologically determined disease. There would be many implications of such a discovery not the least of which might be treatment which is more effective than those currently available. As has been the recent tradition in Biologic Psychiatry, many of these investigations have concerned the genetics of these investigations have concerned the genetics of alcoholism-if the illness is determined to be inherited, then there must be a biologic component to the illness which is encoded in one's deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA). The other primary avenue of study has been to look for biologic differences between alcoholics and to look for biologic differences between alcoholics and their family members and normals. From this investigation we have derived a number of "biologic markers" of alcoholism. Unfortunately, we are still in the embryonic stage of this work, and there are no markers with adequate sensitivity and specificity to predict there are no markers with adequate sensitivity and specificity to predict who will and who will not be alcoholic.

There have been numerous genetic studies published over the past several years. Many of these have been Scandinavian because of the meticulous record- keeping which is done in Denmark. However recently, a number of studies have been conducted in the U.S. Marc Schuckit, M.D. has been one of the primary investigators in this area. His studies indicate that the offspring from two alcoholic biologic parents are four to eight times as likely to develop alcoholism as the general population. This is a strong indicator that there is a heritable trait for alcoholism. The challenge about this type of research often comes in the form of a question about the social/environmental influence of having two alcoholic parents. That is, is the increased likelihood of developing alcoholism due to the biology or to the fact that these children grew up in a home with two alcoholic parents? How can this be studied? Dr. Remi Cadoret at the University of Iowa published an elegant study in the Archives of General Psychiatry in December of 1986 which examined this issue carefully.

Dr. Cadoret's study examined 443 adoptees-infants adopted out of their biologic families at birth. This provides the opportunity to examine both biologic and birth. This provides the opportunity to examine both biologic and environmental effects on the incidence of alcoholism in the offspring. In addition, he was able to examine other factors which might correlate with the development of alcoholism as well. This study led to a number of interesting findings.

1. There was a genetic influence on the development of

alcoholism--children born to alcoholic parents and reared by

non-alcoholic parents developed alcoholism at the rate predicted by the

other genetic studies.

2. Having alcoholic parents also predicted the development of drug

addiction (other than alcoholism).

3. Parents who were addicted, predisposed their biologic offspring to

developing drug addiction and/or alcoholism.

4. Antisocial personality traits seemed to be inherited and to be

biologically associated with drug addiction.

5. Developmental trauma to children not genetically predisposed to the

development of chemical dependency increased the incidence of

development of the disease.

This study clearly separated the biologic and environmental influences on the incidence of alcoholism. In addition, it suggested that alcoholism and other drug addictions may not be different from each other-an idea that many treatment clinicians have suspected for a long time. The study did not discount the idea that developmental experiences may be of importance. Interestingly, the study demonstrated statistical evidence for heritability of what has traditionally been considered to be environmentally determined-personality style (or disorder)

Other investigators who have contributed greatly to the field of genetics of alcoholism are Kaij, Kaprio, Goodwin, Schulsinger, Winokur, Guze and Cloninger.
confused one is offline  
Old 06-03-2004, 03:01 PM
  # 3 (permalink)  
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Txk, Texas
Posts: 5
There have been numerous studies over the past several years looking for specific biologic markers of alcoholism. The idea has been that a biologic marker which is associated with alcoholism will give validity to the disease concept, aid in the diagnosis of the disease and, perhaps, lead to more specific treatments with better outcomes. Although numerous biologic markers have been found, no marker to date has a high sensitivity or specificity and there has been no etiologic association made with any such marker. Despite the disappointing results so far, this line of research is absolutely necessary if we are to improve our understanding of the disease and search for better treatments. There have been no definite cause and effect sequences defined at this point, but the following examples of biologic markers still remain supportive evidence for the concept of alcoholism being a biologic disease.

Tetrahydroisoquinolone (THIQ)- This compound is a condensation product which has been found in the urine of some alcoholics but not in non-alcoholics (or in smaller quantities). THIQ has been found to bind to the delta opioid receptors in the central nervous system and seems to make mice prefer ethanol. The suggestion has been made that this may explain the addiction to alcohol, but this is largely unsupported.

Thyrotropin Releasing Hormone (TRH) Stimulating Test- This test evaluates the function of the hypothalamic-pituitary-thyroid axis. It is used primarily to diagnose diseases of the thyroid gland. Marku Linnoila at the NIAAA has studied this test in alcoholics and their children and found that sons of alcoholic fathers have an abnormal TRH test but daughters do not. He found that these sons (even without phenotypic alcoholism) demonstrated an increase in baseline phenotypic alcoholism) demonstrated an increase in baseline thyrotropin and peak thyrotropin levels after stimulation as compared to the controls.

Alcohol Dehydrogenase and Acetaldehyde Dehydrogenase- These are normal enzymes in the liver which metabolize alcohol to harmless metabolic intermediates. [ethanol is metabolized to acetaldehyde (very toxic substance) by alcohol dehydrogenase and the acetaldehyde is metabolized to acetic acid by acetaldehyde dehydrogenase] There are racial differences in the form of these enzymes. Asians and American Indians have atypical forms of these enzymes (called isoenzymes) have atypical forms of these enzymes (called isoenzymes) such that alcohol is metabolized more rapidly to acetaldehyde and acetaldehyde is metabolized less rapidly to acetic acid. Four percent of the Swiss have been found to possess the atypical ADH isoenzyme whereas 89% of Chinese and 85% of Japanese have atypical aldehyde dehydrogenase. This interesting research was derived from the early investigations of facial flushing among various races. It was noted that approximately 10% of Caucasians experienced facial flushing with acute ingestion facial flushing with acute ingestion of alcohol whereas many more Asians and American Indians had this response. The degree of facial flushing was correlated directly with the concentration of acetaldehyde in breath or blood.

Platelet Monoamine Oxidase (MAO) and Platelet Adenylate Cyclase- Boris Tabakoff and his colleagues at the NIAAA have found that alcoholics do not have different levels of these enzymes on their platelets, but that alcoholics have a different degree of inducibility than normal controls. This is a phenomenon which persists after discontinuation of drinking, however it is not certain at this point whether the abnormal enzyme activities are present prior to the beginning of drinking (i.e., a marker for the development of phenotypic alcoholism) or are a result of exposure to alcohol (i.e., an effect of alcohol). A prospective study needs to be conducted in order to determine this.

[33;1m Progression of Alcohol/Drug Dependency[37;0m

(based on Jellinek chart)
[36;1m Early Stage[37;0m

Drinking to calm nerves Uncomfortable situation where there is no alcohol/drugs Increase in alcohol tolerance Driving while under the influence Desire to continue drinking/using when others stop Relief drinking commences Secret irritation when your drinking/using is discussed Occasional memory lapses after heavy drinking/using Preoccupation with alcohol/drugs (thinking about next drink/drug) Lying about drinking Increasing frequency of relief drinking/using Loss of control phase -- rationalization begins Hiding liquor/drugs; sneaking drinks/drugs Meals missed due to drinking/using

[36;1m Middle Stage[37;0m

Increasing dependence on alcohol/drugs Preoccupation with drinking/drugging activities Drinking/using bolstered with excuses Feeling guilty about drinking/using Irritability when drinking/using is discussed Tremors and early morning drinks/drugs Avoid non-drinking/non-using situations Dishonesty in non-drinking/using activities Increased memory blackouts Loss of other interest/unable to discuss problems Promises and resolutions fail repeatedly Grandiose and aggressive behavior Neglect of food/controlled drinking/using fails Family, work, money problems Family and friends avoided; drinking/using alone (secretly) Possible job loss

[36;1m Late Stage[37;0m

Radical Deterioration of family relationships Now thinks: "responsibilities interfere with my drinking/using" Physical and moral deterioration Unreasonable resentments Loss of "will power" and onset of lengthy drunks/highs Urgent need for morning drink/drug Geographical escape attempted Persistent remorse Impaired thinking and memory loss Successive Lengthy Drunks/highs Loss of family Decrease in alcohol/drug tolerance Hospital/sanitarium Undefinable fears Unable to initiate action; extreme indecisiveness All alibis exhausted Unable to work; obsession with drinking/using Complete abandonment: "I don't care" Continued Deterioration

[36;1m Progression of Recovery[37;0m

Institutionalization or death Calls for help Meets recovering alcoholics/addicts: a ray of hope Learns alcoholism/addiction is a disease Medical help drying out Expresses desire for help Group therapy Starts to react to help from other alcoholics/addicts Pride in appearance is renewed Realizes alcoholism/addiction can be arrested Begins to get honest with self Spiritual needs examined Dawn of new hope Belief that a new life is possible Interest in group therapy and others grows Spiritual values develop Thinking becomes more realistic Natural rest/sleep and appetite return Your family and friends notice change and growth Diminishing fears and anxieties Self esteem starts to return A new set of values develops - with honest training New circle of friends offer encouragement Readjustment of needs to self and family Future is faced with new positive attitudes New interests develop Increase in emotional stability Sense of financial responsibilities returns Rebirth of ideals Return of vocational confidence and quality Activities with others increases Contentment in sobriety unfolds A new appreciation of spiritual values Improved peace of mind Rationalizations recognized Increasing tolerance Recovery and sobriety continue Action is the magic word Working with others Recovery [1m^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ END OF FILE ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^[0m

confused one is offline  
Old 06-03-2004, 03:07 PM
  # 4 (permalink)  
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Txk, Texas
Posts: 5

A Disease?

if so:

It is the only disease contracted by an act of will;

It is the only disease that is habit forming;

It is the only disease that comes in a bottle;

It is the only disease causing hundreds of thousands of family disruptions;

It is the only disease promoting crime and brutality;

It is the only disease playing a major part in over 50 percent of highway deaths;

It is the only disease which is sold by license;

It is the only disease that is bought in grocery stores, drug stores, and well-marked retail outlets;

It is the only disease that is taxed by the governmant;

It is the only disease in which medical support for the disease outweighs any effort to prevent it;

It is the only disease advocated by almost all of the advertising media;

It is the only disease given as a Christmas gift;

It is the only disease that is checked by government inspectors to make sure the poison is pure.
confused one is offline  
Old 06-03-2004, 03:20 PM
  # 5 (permalink)  
Dancing To My Own Beat
Magichappens's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: I don't know what kind of state I'm in
Posts: 1,326
Alcohol is not a disease. The disease of alcoholism isn't present in everyone who drinks alcohol. Alcohol is not the problem. Drinking to extreme is but a symptom of the disease. Alcoholism is a mental, physical, and spiritual malady that manifests in self-medication.
Magichappens is offline  
Old 06-03-2004, 06:59 PM
  # 6 (permalink)  
once in a . . .
BlueMoon's Avatar
Join Date: May 2004
Location: looking in / looking out
Posts: 1,214
Blog Entries: 84
wholeheartedly and emphatically agree with Magic!

BlueMoon is offline  
Old 06-04-2004, 06:39 AM
  # 7 (permalink)  
Thread Starter
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Txk, Texas
Posts: 5
I also agree. I wanted to find articles on the internet for and against it being called a disease. I do not think it should be called a disease. By looking on the internet, it seems to be an on going debate.
confused one is offline  
Old 06-04-2004, 07:06 AM
  # 8 (permalink)  
Dancing To My Own Beat
Magichappens's Avatar
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: I don't know what kind of state I'm in
Posts: 1,326
The main reason that AA refers to it as a disease is because the foundation of AA is the first step "We admitted we were powerless over alcohol, that our lives had become unmanageable." It's symantics and splitting hairs for me. Whatever we call it, I don't have it. My husband does. He is the one who is responsible for the consequences of and recovery from alcoholism. I am responsible for the recovery from the effects on me. I have to focus on myself and not the alcoholic. I have to learn that whether I accept that he is powerless or not, my resentment and blaming is only hurting myself. There is no solution in blaming the alcoholic for where I am in my life. I take responsibility for moving forward and not clinging to the past wrongs that were done to me. That has taken a lot of working the steps, prayer, time, and support of the people in recovery. I thank God every day for what Alanon has given me. Hugs, Magic
Magichappens is offline  
Old 06-04-2004, 07:19 AM
  # 9 (permalink)  
Lorelai's Avatar
Join Date: Apr 2004
Location: Star's Hollow
Posts: 615
The definition of disease is "an unhealthy condition" which is, of course, perfectly apt.

Calling it a disease makes it harder on me - plain and simple. It gets me right back onto that "feeling sorry for him" merry-go-round which is not a good ride for me to be on. I know there are many valid arguments for calling alcoholism a disease. The definition of "disease" in my mind is different than Webster's but that is something I have to work on along with everything else ! LOL
Lorelai is offline  

Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Rules
You may not post new threads
You may not post replies
You may not post attachments
You may not edit your posts

BB code is On
Smilies are On
[IMG] code is On
HTML code is Off
Trackbacks are On
Pingbacks are On
Refbacks are Off

All times are GMT -7. The time now is 04:17 AM.