New Article on Addiction from the NY Times
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: New York
Posts: 106
New Article on Addiction from the NY Times
The Fallacy of the 'Hijacked Brain' - NYTimes.com
Haven't read it yet, but will and re-post with discussion. Enjoy!
Haven't read it yet, but will and re-post with discussion. Enjoy!
Her ending is okay:
"The complexity of each person’s experience with addiction should caution us to avoid false quandaries, like the one that requires us to define addiction as either disease or choice, and to adopt more nuanced conceptions. Addicts are neither hijackers nor victims. It is time to retire this analogy."
"The complexity of each person’s experience with addiction should caution us to avoid false quandaries, like the one that requires us to define addiction as either disease or choice, and to adopt more nuanced conceptions. Addicts are neither hijackers nor victims. It is time to retire this analogy."
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: New York
Posts: 106
A person who knows he meets the D.S.M.-IV criteria for chemical abuse, and that abuse is often the precursor to dependency, and still continues to use drugs, is making a choice, and thus bears responsibility for it.
There's another aspect of responsibility not talked about here which is the responsibility the individual has to seek treatment. Just like with the diabetic, he must continue to avoid sweets if he wishes to avoid the downfalls of his disease, and as with the addict.
I wouldn't really say I learned anything new here, though.
And MattM, just curious why you "don't respect" philosophy. I mean, do you mean all of philosophy? Or just one area?
For some reason, this makes me feel better about my addiction. Cus I don't want to know that I'm consciously making this choice to drink. Not knowing what is making me drink, is hellish enough. I can't be ok with people losing families, loved ones, neglect children, become homless or die, for the sake of a drink/hit. Something clearly isn't right within our brain. No person wants this for themselves, loved ones or family.
What the hell is wrong with us? Why are there addicts in the world? What makes us become this? What makes people die from this? What makes people neglect and continuously hurt the people they love?
Please...tell me there some science behind it! Tell me its not something Im doing on purpose.
What the hell is wrong with us? Why are there addicts in the world? What makes us become this? What makes people die from this? What makes people neglect and continuously hurt the people they love?
Please...tell me there some science behind it! Tell me its not something Im doing on purpose.
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2012
Location: New York
Posts: 106
Simplyfab, I don't know if this will be apropos, but it's helped me in thinking about this the last week or so. I'm reading this book on Buddhism and in the first chapter, there is a young man plagued by Dispassion and begs to be relieved of it by some Buddhist sages. Dispassion is, I have taken to be, the feeling of "Why bother," or "What's there to live for," or "Why should I try to be any better?"
These have always been feelings that have plagued me and sometimes allowed me to engage in destructive behavior.
I'm changing that now (Thank G-d!), with the help of my 12-steps, but also my meditation practice and the group I meet with to discuss texts like the one I'm describing.
Anyway, in the story, the Buddhist sage replies that the Only way to find salvation is to start from a point of Dispassion. So, looked at in this light, we are on a spiritual path, but one does not have the desire to Truly find spiritualism until one has come to find their place of Dispassion, or "Hit one's bottom".
I think, though, now it is up to us to continue on the road to spiritual awakening knowing we are more sensitive to the Dispassion of this world.
I don;t know, that's been helping me, at least!
These have always been feelings that have plagued me and sometimes allowed me to engage in destructive behavior.
I'm changing that now (Thank G-d!), with the help of my 12-steps, but also my meditation practice and the group I meet with to discuss texts like the one I'm describing.
Anyway, in the story, the Buddhist sage replies that the Only way to find salvation is to start from a point of Dispassion. So, looked at in this light, we are on a spiritual path, but one does not have the desire to Truly find spiritualism until one has come to find their place of Dispassion, or "Hit one's bottom".
I think, though, now it is up to us to continue on the road to spiritual awakening knowing we are more sensitive to the Dispassion of this world.
I don;t know, that's been helping me, at least!
And at the end of the day, I'm not sure I can put my finger on it.
I think, that when I started reading philosophy in college, I thought that logic and intellect could provide a foundation to replace the religion that I'd turned my back on.
But I think I found that for every apparently sound argument that one philosopher could muster...10 other philosophers could put forth equally compelling counter arguments. And ultimately, when I clawed my way to the very bottom of this pile of arguments and counter-arguments to see what philosophy rests on...there is no "there" there. Logic is a useful tool...but it doesn't help me lead a better life.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)