An online discussion about depression I was having
An online discussion about depression I was having
This is from another board and another discussion I was having. I thought I would pass it on.
Lets take Depression for instance. Lets look at a PET scan of a depressed person and healthy person
On the left you will see a healthy person, on the right is a person suffering from depression.
The highlighted red spot is where active nuerotransmitters are firing. If you see on the left side a very strong band of red in the pons and frontal lobe. The right side is much more sporadic and spread out. This is due to less nuerotransmitters firing. It literally means it "slows" down their thinking thus affecting their mood.
Ok how do you fix it? Here pinkCuda and I agree. Therapy does work! People who suffer from mild to moderate forms of depression respond to therapy as well as medications! Yet in the worst of the worst cases such as in the case above, it doesn't work. This is where medications are needed.
A good analogy of medicaitons is Antidepressants are like a really good set of spark plug wires. They overcome the loss or lack of nuerotransmitters and allows people get a adequate dose of nuerotransmitters to function. I think in this case its needed.
Lets take Depression for instance. Lets look at a PET scan of a depressed person and healthy person
On the left you will see a healthy person, on the right is a person suffering from depression.
The highlighted red spot is where active nuerotransmitters are firing. If you see on the left side a very strong band of red in the pons and frontal lobe. The right side is much more sporadic and spread out. This is due to less nuerotransmitters firing. It literally means it "slows" down their thinking thus affecting their mood.
Ok how do you fix it? Here pinkCuda and I agree. Therapy does work! People who suffer from mild to moderate forms of depression respond to therapy as well as medications! Yet in the worst of the worst cases such as in the case above, it doesn't work. This is where medications are needed.
A good analogy of medicaitons is Antidepressants are like a really good set of spark plug wires. They overcome the loss or lack of nuerotransmitters and allows people get a adequate dose of nuerotransmitters to function. I think in this case its needed.
Ok how do you fix it? Here pinkCuda and I agree. Therapy does work! People who suffer from mild to moderate forms of depression respond to therapy as well as medications! Yet in the worst of the worst cases such as in the case above, it doesn't work. This is where medications are needed.
A good analogy of medicaitons is Antidepressants are like a really good set of spark plug wires. They overcome the loss or lack of nuerotransmitters and allows people get a adequate dose of nuerotransmitters to function. I think in this case its needed.
A good analogy of medicaitons is Antidepressants are like a really good set of spark plug wires. They overcome the loss or lack of nuerotransmitters and allows people get a adequate dose of nuerotransmitters to function. I think in this case its needed.
Personally I have a depression that is chemical. I am sure if a scan was done on my brain it would look very much like the one in your pictures. I can tell the difference between situational depression and the chemical depression. The situation depression I have been able to treat by utilizing the steps of AA. But the chemical depression the kind that when not being treated with medication, tells me as the first thought in my head when I wake up "put a gun to your head" while the logical side of my brain is screaming "Why! There is no reason to, life is fine." That is the kind of depression that I have to treat with antidepressants. It is insanity for me not to as it boils down to Russian Roulette on a daily basis if I don't.
That is why I will not discourage the use of antidepressants to anyone as I do not live in their head and I am not qualified to determine the depth or type of their depression.
Cool pictures.
Even situational depression causes chemical changes. With a life time of situations you can be messed up chemically even when all is well like you say. If that makes any sense. I am learning to fight my depression but only meds has helped me to get to that point. I am happy to say that after 10 years of anti depressants i am only on a low dose of mood stabilizer now.
Even situational depression causes chemical changes. With a life time of situations you can be messed up chemically even when all is well like you say. If that makes any sense. I am learning to fight my depression but only meds has helped me to get to that point. I am happy to say that after 10 years of anti depressants i am only on a low dose of mood stabilizer now.
Forward we go...side by side-Rest In Peace
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Serene In Dixie
Posts: 36,740
My long term depression is why I began AA recovery.
Fortunantly, mine was situational depression
It started to lift quickly ...by 3 months sober
it vanished. It's never returned.
You need a medical diagnosis to determine what type
of depression is present. Sometimes meds are required.
However...from my experience and observations...
alcohol never is a long term solution to depression.
Fortunantly, mine was situational depression
It started to lift quickly ...by 3 months sober
it vanished. It's never returned.
You need a medical diagnosis to determine what type
of depression is present. Sometimes meds are required.
However...from my experience and observations...
alcohol never is a long term solution to depression.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)