Would you drink if you could?
I made what is called a Big Plan, a solemn vow to never drink NO MATTER WHAT. Unconditional permanent sobriety is what I have signed up for. So that means that nothing could ever happen that would lead me back to drinking, including a consequence free bender. I've already asked all those questions and answered them for myself.
Well youngandclean your list really didn't cover the areas where I had most problems. You mentioned: financial, relationship, legal, health.
I didn't have too many problems in those areas. I had problems with insanity and emotional illness.
You defined alcohol problems as being external, so I guess that you considered your internal processes unaffected by alcohol? In that case maybe you could drink if you could.
The first sip makes me experience instant and radical mood swings, and after 5 drinks the mental instability sets in. I wouldn't drink again because I can't.
I didn't have too many problems in those areas. I had problems with insanity and emotional illness.
You defined alcohol problems as being external, so I guess that you considered your internal processes unaffected by alcohol? In that case maybe you could drink if you could.
The first sip makes me experience instant and radical mood swings, and after 5 drinks the mental instability sets in. I wouldn't drink again because I can't.
If you can say yes to this then you still have an active love affair with alcohol. Once I lost my love for alcohol I never have had a desire to drink again. It is romancing the habit to still think hypothetically like this and has to still be lurking just beneath the surface.
I left the habit several months ago for dead and wouldn't have it any other way. The minute I start to think like this I better seek counsel because my mindset is in the wrong place.
I left the habit several months ago for dead and wouldn't have it any other way. The minute I start to think like this I better seek counsel because my mindset is in the wrong place.
I hit day 50 today and I'm probably still too early on to say no to that question...
That being said I have no intention of breaking my streak. I'm finding the compulsions easing as time goes on.
Also, I would not call my relationship with alcohol a "love affair". Maybe more like having a dishonest, selfish business partner who can put one over on you in a heartbeat.
That being said I have no intention of breaking my streak. I'm finding the compulsions easing as time goes on.
Also, I would not call my relationship with alcohol a "love affair". Maybe more like having a dishonest, selfish business partner who can put one over on you in a heartbeat.
Member
Join Date: Jan 2014
Posts: 3,293
If you can say yes to this then you still have an active love affair with alcohol. Once I lost my love for alcohol I never have had a desire to drink again. It is romancing the habit to still think hypothetically like this and has to still be lurking just beneath the surface.
I left the habit several months ago for dead and wouldn't have it any other way. The minute I start to think like this I better seek counsel because my mindset is in the wrong place.
I left the habit several months ago for dead and wouldn't have it any other way. The minute I start to think like this I better seek counsel because my mindset is in the wrong place.
Yes, I do have a love affair with alcohol, a dysfunctional one. I had an intense relationship with someone a while ago. It was also dysfunctional, and I would never get involved with her again, even though I still care about her. She would just pick up where she left off and destroy my life just like alcohol would if I allowed it. Just sayin.
I can say without a shadow of a doubt that I don't ever want to feel that buzzed feeling again. It's no longer equated with enjoyment. Only the aftermath of what occurs when I get that way.
Why even bother entertaining the thought?
Why even bother entertaining the thought?
I was actually thinking about this during a meeting last night reading the part in the big book that may be one day science would find a way for that to happen or something along those lines and right now, I would probably say no. See, I pray every day for God to remove the alcohol obsession from me and it usually works. I am happy that many days I have no desire or craving to drink.
Member
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: na
Posts: 151
Yes, I would. In another world, I would be drinker like many of my friends. Pick up once a week or maybe once every two weeks, have a few glasses of wine a couple nights week, relax with friends over margaritas, etc. Sure. Why not? Would have loved to have stabilized as a moderate drinker.
obviously not possible.
obviously not possible.
Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Portland, OR
Posts: 321
I'm not going to kid myself or anyone else. I love drinking, and smoking pot. It took a lot of pain for me to finally get the willingness to do something other then use and drink. If I could drink without causing more pain, without experiencing unmanageablitity, I would. I'm not cured of that desire, or of the disease of alcoholism. That's the reason I still go to meetings and do the work. If I don't I will drink.
For now, I wish I could drink, but I hope there will be a day where I no longer crave it. I wish I can have a casual drink like a lot of the people I know, but that most likely will never happen, and I don't want to try and trick myself into thinking it will.
Yes if there were absolutely no consequences I would drink. I quit because of the consequences and I'm at peace with the fact I can't drink. I actually enjoy it most of the time.
Hypothetically though if you removed all the pain drinking caused and left only the good I find it hard to believe so many wouldn't.
Hypothetically though if you removed all the pain drinking caused and left only the good I find it hard to believe so many wouldn't.
I was reading the "Chapter to the Agnostics" in the Big Book of AA and it mentioned a man who having had a spiritual experience, no longer wished to drink even if he could.
Im curious, if you could drink without the financial, relationship, legal, health problems associated with alcoholism, would you?
Im curious, if you could drink without the financial, relationship, legal, health problems associated with alcoholism, would you?
I don't go along with the notion of 'normal' drinkers. People drink to get an altered state. For the type of drinker who has a glass of champagne at a wedding, it may be only a slightly altered state of feeling more relaxed in a social setting but they consume the drug alcohol for its mind altering effects. I dont see how this is more normal than a person who drinks more frequently, or larger quantities or whatever. The only exception to this in my view are the few people who really don't like drinking but do it occasionally to 'fit in'.
I am only sober a few weeks.occasionally the thought of drinking turns my stomach. Long may it continue. Drinking offers NOTHING.
I am only sober a few weeks.occasionally the thought of drinking turns my stomach. Long may it continue. Drinking offers NOTHING.
I can drink. I choose not to.
If you're asking me if I could remove all of the costs, risks, and side effects associated with drinking, would I do it?
My answer would still be No.
Life is like the seasons, and I am in my autumn. I enjoyed the summer season of my life but I have no desire to relive it. Aristotle once said that we are never standing still. Rather, we are constantly spiraling, either up, or down.
I agree with that statement.
If you're asking me if I could remove all of the costs, risks, and side effects associated with drinking, would I do it?
My answer would still be No.
Life is like the seasons, and I am in my autumn. I enjoyed the summer season of my life but I have no desire to relive it. Aristotle once said that we are never standing still. Rather, we are constantly spiraling, either up, or down.
I agree with that statement.
God I LOVE that ... Being in the autumn of your live!!! That really strikes a chord with me because I do wonder about all the "fun times" being some now that the party is over.... I guess it's ok to enjoy a stiller peaceful healthier time of my life!
In my thirties a six pack lasted a month or two in my fridge. In the last two years before I quit at 58 a six pack got me through 9am - 11am. That was after my three or four shots in my coffee. I am 61 now, and very much living the life retired with no worries about me any more. I am at cause now, no longer at effect.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)