I Don't Think Alcoholism is Real
Member
Join Date: Dec 2012
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 31
That's a great little story, but really what is the point of it? Are you trying to convince us or yourself? This is a site to support people struggling with addiciton issues, if that clearly is not you, then why are you here? I don't have an eating disorder or struggle with gambling, but you don't see me spouting my useless propaganda on their websites. So again, I am confused as to why you are here.
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2013
Posts: 2
I've found that I do get used to certain behaviors. For example, if I sit and watch tv every day from 10pm to 11pm for a week, that's all I want to do at that time every day. If I go to the gym every day at noon for a week, I design my day to be able to do that every day, and if I can't, I crave it or miss it. I think that was with my drinking as well. I fell into a pattern of doing something so I kept doing it. Once I stopped the pattern, things become easy. I think, at least for me, it was more of getting used to a pattern then on getting addicted to the alcohol.
Just starving for attention I bet.
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: "I'm not lost for I know where I am. But however, where I am may be lost ..."
Posts: 5,273
Originally Posted by BadCompany
And what about all those people that claim to be "allergic" to peanuts and strawberries and such. I can eat them no problem. I think they are all faking.
I've found that I do get used to certain behaviors. For example, if I sit and watch tv every day from 10pm to 11pm for a week, that's all I want to do at that time every day. If I go to the gym every day at noon for a week, I design my day to be able to do that every day, and if I can't, I crave it or miss it. I think that was with my drinking as well. I fell into a pattern of doing something so I kept doing it. Once I stopped the pattern, things become easy. I think, at least for me, it was more of getting used to a pattern then on getting addicted to the alcohol.
The reality of this 'whatever you want to call it' is;
The economic costs of excessive alcohol consumption in 2006 were estimated at $223.5 billion.
80,000 deaths attributable to excessive alcohol use each year in the United States.
CDC - Fact Sheets-Alcohol Use And Health - Alcohol
The reality is that the absolute vast majority of persons who are alcohol dependent, will not be able to one day successfully moderate the consumption of alcohol. If someone wants to get well and leave the destructive behaviour behind, their surest means of achieving long term sobriety is via abstinence.
Yes, there are a very small number of addicts who learn how to successfully moderate. No one in this thread has denied this reality.
Best of luck two you and I still don't know why you, without a drinking problem, are on a drinking problem web forum?
Audrey Kishline had the same ideas when she wrote the book "''Moderate Drinking: The New Option for Problem Drinkers" and look where it got her.
You sound like what we call in Australia a "P*ss Head", that is someone who can drink himself sober, do it every night and still take it or leave it. A type of "Hard Drinker" not an alcoholic per se.
I know a guy over here who has been bitten by about 3 different venemous snakes and has developed immunity. I have friends that drink and drug but don't use when they would rather not. Some people get sick, some don't. Some get immunity, some get addicted.
Think yourself lucky but don't get complacent. It has a way of sneaking up on you.
You sound like what we call in Australia a "P*ss Head", that is someone who can drink himself sober, do it every night and still take it or leave it. A type of "Hard Drinker" not an alcoholic per se.
I know a guy over here who has been bitten by about 3 different venemous snakes and has developed immunity. I have friends that drink and drug but don't use when they would rather not. Some people get sick, some don't. Some get immunity, some get addicted.
Think yourself lucky but don't get complacent. It has a way of sneaking up on you.
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: "I'm not lost for I know where I am. But however, where I am may be lost ..."
Posts: 5,273
Originally Posted by Xune
80,000 deaths attributable to excessive alcohol use each year in the United States.
you dont have to believe it is a disease, and if yer still drinking and can control it, hats off to you, but i really dont know why this was even posted on a site named sober recovery.
I would say you just never became physically addicted. Lots of people drink stupidly in college or during military service and later slow down. I know I've tried for years to drink with restraint and it just ain't happening.
It's the same as saying that diabetes isn't real, or diabetes is greatly exaggerated, because you personally used to eat a lot of sweets, and suddenly stopped.
Don't quit your day job. Your days as a expert on alcoholism are numbered.
I'm burying a friend on Friday who felt that he could control his drinking.
Zube
Member
Join Date: Oct 2012
Posts: 162
Not to derail, but I think that is the one thing that sometimes leads me to questioning whether or not I have a "problem" (I do know that I have a problem, but that doesn't stop me from questioning it occassionally )...
I read about all of these horrible withdrawl experiences that people have, yet of all the times I've "quit", I've never had any physical withdrawl symptoms... And I've been drinking A LOT for a LONG TIME (up until a couple of months ago)... Minimum of 12 beers a night and usually closer to a case during the week for at least the past decade, and much more than that on the weekends...
How rare is this I wonder???
I read about all of these horrible withdrawl experiences that people have, yet of all the times I've "quit", I've never had any physical withdrawl symptoms... And I've been drinking A LOT for a LONG TIME (up until a couple of months ago)... Minimum of 12 beers a night and usually closer to a case during the week for at least the past decade, and much more than that on the weekends...
How rare is this I wonder???
Originally Posted by TheEnd
That's a great little story, but really what is the point of it? Are you trying to convince us or yourself? This is a site to support people struggling with addiciton issues, if that clearly is not you, then why are you here? I don't have an eating disorder or struggle with gambling, but you don't see me spouting my useless propaganda on their websites. So again, I am confused as to why you are here.
Tomsteve:
you dont have to believe it is a disease, and if yer still drinking and can control it, hats off to you, but i really dont know why this was even posted on a site named sober recovery.
What these two said.
Personally, I do not know what kind of response you were expecting on a sober recovery site? More power to ya for being able to learn to drink responsibly after 10 years of alcohol abuse/alcoholic activity but majority of us can't. You are the exception along with not many few others. Me and a lot of other people here on SR tried to moderate our drinking or learn how to drink responsibly and it almost killed a lot of us in the process. Why the heck do you think we are members of this site trying to remain sober? Because our lives depend on it in most cases. You aren't trying to get and stay sober so why are you here, again....seriously this baffles me.
Blahhh what's the use? Wasted energy blows!
Best of luck to ya and I will keep you in my prayers cause I think you are trying to convince yourself with this thread. The whole ordeal doesn't make much sense really....
it really does take all kinds....and that's OK.
That's a great little story, but really what is the point of it? Are you trying to convince us or yourself? This is a site to support people struggling with addiciton issues, if that clearly is not you, then why are you here? I don't have an eating disorder or struggle with gambling, but you don't see me spouting my useless propaganda on their websites. So again, I am confused as to why you are here.
Tomsteve:
you dont have to believe it is a disease, and if yer still drinking and can control it, hats off to you, but i really dont know why this was even posted on a site named sober recovery.
What these two said.
Personally, I do not know what kind of response you were expecting on a sober recovery site? More power to ya for being able to learn to drink responsibly after 10 years of alcohol abuse/alcoholic activity but majority of us can't. You are the exception along with not many few others. Me and a lot of other people here on SR tried to moderate our drinking or learn how to drink responsibly and it almost killed a lot of us in the process. Why the heck do you think we are members of this site trying to remain sober? Because our lives depend on it in most cases. You aren't trying to get and stay sober so why are you here, again....seriously this baffles me.
Blahhh what's the use? Wasted energy blows!
Best of luck to ya and I will keep you in my prayers cause I think you are trying to convince yourself with this thread. The whole ordeal doesn't make much sense really....
it really does take all kinds....and that's OK.
Well Jason I am not sure what you want us to say! I think you just posted on the wrong thread. Perhaps you should find a forum of like minded people that would be very interested in your theory.
If you want to let us know how well you can handle alcohol,,,,more power to you! Although there is a very strong possibility your not even an alcoholic---so no biggy and have at it
TrixMixer
theres a lot of people in early recovery on this site. i hope and pray none of them reads this and gets the thought in their head that maybe they dont have a problem, maybe they arent alcoholic and decide to try drinking again.
and this is what can happen:
http://www.soberrecovery.com/forums/...-back-out.html
http://www.soberrecovery.com/forums/...-back-out.html
Well, I think there is some good that can come of Jason's thread.... Isn't his perception the same as many people out there that have little or no experience with alcoholism? ... I see this as an awesome opportunity to educate Jason and any of our lurkers out there who believe that alcoholism is just a bad habit... It was for Jason, and from his POV...
Welcome to SR, Jason!!!
Welcome to SR, Jason!!!
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)