Disappointed in AA
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 341
Disappointed in AA
Hello all. I just got finished detoxing in the hospital and went through some pretty bad DTs. I have detoxed in the past and this was the worst detox yet with delusional thoughts and hallucinations. I thought I was a goner for sure.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
Wernicke
Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Getting to where I want to be
Posts: 502
Hello all. I just got finished detoxing in the hospital and went through some pretty bad DTs. I have detoxed in the past and this was the worst detox yet with delusional thoughts and hallucinations. I thought I was a goner for sure.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
I could see the concern on those peoples faces. After the meeting at least a dozen people came up to me, talked to me, encouraged me, hugged me. The only person I knew there was my sponsor.
Is it possible you misunderstood? Perhaps the guy was well known there and was just being good-naturely teased?
Powerless over Alcohol
Join Date: May 2011
Location: Trudging the Road to Happy Destiny!
Posts: 4,018
Sorry about that. Unfotuanlely everyone is only human and some dont work a good program. That is not the normal.
I was diagosed with wet brain or Korsakoff syndrom at 39 after detoxing in coutny jail. So badly my hallucunations had me running head first into the cell wall. And 2 days woke up in the ICU at the Cleveland Clinic. Being told of what I had , lucky for me the thiamine treatments they gave me brought me back. But nobody should be laughing at anyone there. I cant believe noone put a stop to it.
I hope you can talk to those people and tell them what you felt and hopefully try some different meetings.
Glad you made throu detox and came and posted.
I was diagosed with wet brain or Korsakoff syndrom at 39 after detoxing in coutny jail. So badly my hallucunations had me running head first into the cell wall. And 2 days woke up in the ICU at the Cleveland Clinic. Being told of what I had , lucky for me the thiamine treatments they gave me brought me back. But nobody should be laughing at anyone there. I cant believe noone put a stop to it.
I hope you can talk to those people and tell them what you felt and hopefully try some different meetings.
Glad you made throu detox and came and posted.
it happens. i live in small town northern michigan and it happens. some people are not very mentally and emotionally sober and stuck in the middle school mentality. there are many different levels/stages of sobriety goin on in AA and length of sobriety doesnt always determine where a person is mentally and emotionally. some dont want to grow. some dont want to let go fo those defects/shortcomings. it happens.
the thing for me to do is remember they are sick people. do i want what they have? if no, i stay away. seek out the fellowship you crave and it will appear.
maybe bring up the topic of love and tolerance is our code at a meeting and see what ya hear. it may also help ya find a sponsor.
good on ya for gettin back to AA after detox.
the thing for me to do is remember they are sick people. do i want what they have? if no, i stay away. seek out the fellowship you crave and it will appear.
maybe bring up the topic of love and tolerance is our code at a meeting and see what ya hear. it may also help ya find a sponsor.
good on ya for gettin back to AA after detox.
I think this experience should be a wake up call to ALL of us, not just AA folks. This could happen in any recovery meeting, not just AA meetings. It's critical to remember that people with addictions often are sick, often struggle, often "don't get it", often are extremely vulnerable, but ALWAYS deserve compassion and concern, particularly from those of us who have found a comfortable recovery for ourselves. I would hope that any time any one of us sees such behavior we'll do all we can to stop it.
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 341
It was mostly giggles from people and a man across from me kept rolling his eyes. The individual was talking about things off topic and about how he had telepathy. I guess I'm the only one who thought he was really sick because others seemed annoyed that he kept talking. Like he was a waste of time. Wet brain seems about right. He had been in jail and probably never received help for detox. Sad.
Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Canada. About as far south as you can get
Posts: 4,768
It was mostly giggles from people and a man across from me kept rolling his eyes. The individual was talking about things off topic and about how he had telepathy. I guess I'm the only one who thought he was really sick because others seemed annoyed that he kept talking. Like he was a waste of time. Wet brain seems about right. He had been in jail and probably never received help for detox. Sad.
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
There definitely are meetings that I have left feeling the same way. The best I can do is be the change I wish to see at that meeting. Seems like you did the right thing.
Try some other meetings. Like alcoholics, some meetings are sicker than others. They seem to have lost touch with the real message, but there are some great groups out there and youll find'em.
God Bless!
Try some other meetings. Like alcoholics, some meetings are sicker than others. They seem to have lost touch with the real message, but there are some great groups out there and youll find'em.
God Bless!
You do realize that in an AA clubroom is the biggest bunch of sick puppies that you could ever imagine. The worst lying, cheating, backstabbing, denying, covering up, perverted, dysfunctional, selfish, arrogant, manipulating, childish, hopeless, helpless, deeply flawed people that you could ever assemble in one place .... and once in a while some of them have a bad day.
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Hello all. I just got finished detoxing in the hospital and went through some pretty bad DTs. I have detoxed in the past and this was the worst detox yet with delusional thoughts and hallucinations. I thought I was a goner for sure.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
I am a week sober now and am still in panic mode and forming sentences is hard so bear with me. I forced myself back to my old AA meeting last night and we were told to read tradition 7 from a book then discuss. I passed. An older man next to me started rambling. He went off on somewhat of a tangent and seemed to be either in detox or have brain damage from years of alcohol abuse (He was talking like my grampa who died from alcoholism).
I was shocked because I felt bad that the man couldn't form a sentence and other members of the meeting were actually laughing at him right then and there as he continued on. Members poked fun at him when he is a reminder of what we all could be if we keep drinking. I thought AA was supposed to be a place for compassion and healing and I left this meeting disgusted. We have other meetings in this town with the same members which I will not be attending. This man clearly wasn't drunk and after the meeting I talked to him about what a horrible disease alcoholism is. I dunno, I guess I need some faith restored here. Thanks.
Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Getting to where I want to be
Posts: 502
You do realize that in an AA clubroom is the biggest bunch of sick puppies that you could ever imagine. The worst lying, cheating, backstabbing, denying, covering up, perverted, dysfunctional, selfish, arrogant, manipulating, childish, hopeless, helpless, deeply flawed people that you could ever assemble in one place .... and once in a while some of them have a bad day.
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Member
Join Date: Dec 2011
Location: Between Meetings
Posts: 8,997
You do realize that in an AA clubroom is the biggest bunch of sick puppies that you could ever imagine. The worst lying, cheating, backstabbing, denying, covering up, perverted, dysfunctional, selfish, arrogant, manipulating, childish, hopeless, helpless, deeply flawed people that you could ever assemble in one place .... and once in a while some of them have a bad day.
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Don't let what you saw color your perception of AA. Learn from it and grow.
All the best.
Bob R
Member
Join Date: Apr 2012
Location: Getting to where I want to be
Posts: 502
Most AA meetings take place in churches, senior centers or community buildings. There are some buildings fully rented by an AA group which are dedicated to meetings. Some allow members to hang out there most of the day. These are known as clubhouses. Members pay additional dues to be members of the clubhouse.
Behindblueyes,
After reading your post I was trying to formulate some written response that would help you, if that is what you are looking for in this post, find a way to keep attending AA meetings for your own good. Obviously if I read your post correctly you need something that will help you overcome your alcohol issues.
The best I came up with was that when I first decided to attend AA meetings it was because I had run out of other options and my drinking was killing me physically, emotionally and socially. I most certainly did not go to AA because I wanted to.
My expectations of an AA meeting were so low that if they had conducted public floggings and exorcised demons I would not have been surprised. No amount of bizarre behavior, rudeness and inappropriate comments really shocked me. I stayed because I had to get sober, for me and AA was the only place I knew of where that was the primary order of business.
My point is that by having NO expectations and preconceived notions of what AA should or shouldn't be I just sat there listening, trying to understand the whole 12 step thing and gradually made the acquaintance and later made friends with those people in the rooms who had what I wanted. I did what those people did and over the next several years by not drinking and trying to live a life of value and integrity and compassion I have really got my money’s worth if you will, from AA.
I try not to be someone that will deter a new person from attending and try by example to be that fellow that the new guy wants to have what I have. There are still all sorts of strange people in AA meetings and behavior that I am often amazed at. Me, I just go happily on my way trying to add and not detract from a fellowship that gave me back my life in the last century.
Expect the least possible and try and give the most and at least at the end of that meeting you won't be one of the people that your parents warned you about!
Best wishes,
Jon
After reading your post I was trying to formulate some written response that would help you, if that is what you are looking for in this post, find a way to keep attending AA meetings for your own good. Obviously if I read your post correctly you need something that will help you overcome your alcohol issues.
The best I came up with was that when I first decided to attend AA meetings it was because I had run out of other options and my drinking was killing me physically, emotionally and socially. I most certainly did not go to AA because I wanted to.
My expectations of an AA meeting were so low that if they had conducted public floggings and exorcised demons I would not have been surprised. No amount of bizarre behavior, rudeness and inappropriate comments really shocked me. I stayed because I had to get sober, for me and AA was the only place I knew of where that was the primary order of business.
My point is that by having NO expectations and preconceived notions of what AA should or shouldn't be I just sat there listening, trying to understand the whole 12 step thing and gradually made the acquaintance and later made friends with those people in the rooms who had what I wanted. I did what those people did and over the next several years by not drinking and trying to live a life of value and integrity and compassion I have really got my money’s worth if you will, from AA.
I try not to be someone that will deter a new person from attending and try by example to be that fellow that the new guy wants to have what I have. There are still all sorts of strange people in AA meetings and behavior that I am often amazed at. Me, I just go happily on my way trying to add and not detract from a fellowship that gave me back my life in the last century.
Expect the least possible and try and give the most and at least at the end of that meeting you won't be one of the people that your parents warned you about!
Best wishes,
Jon
Your attitude, not your aptitude, will determine your altitude
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Oxnard (The Nard), CA, USA.
Posts: 13,941
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)