WHO launches worldwide war on booze
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 1,292
WHO launches worldwide war on booze
Looks like they are going to try and make alcohol as socially unacceptable as smoking. Good intentions but I doubt it will work. Education is crucial though.
WHO launches worldwide war on booze - health - 14 October 2009 - New Scientist
WHO launches worldwide war on booze - health - 14 October 2009 - New Scientist
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
I hate it when people who want to legislate good behavior - and "good" always means their idea of good.
Educating people and then letting them make their own decisions is what works. It was education, not additional taxes, that made fewer people smoke. Alcohol lands more teenagers in the emergency room and morgue than any other drug by far, but the US government spends the taxpayer's PSA money exclusively on preventing marijuana use. It's just a ridiculous abuse of resources.
Educating people and then letting them make their own decisions is what works. It was education, not additional taxes, that made fewer people smoke. Alcohol lands more teenagers in the emergency room and morgue than any other drug by far, but the US government spends the taxpayer's PSA money exclusively on preventing marijuana use. It's just a ridiculous abuse of resources.
Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 74
Prohibition drove alcoholism underground. Did nothing to solve alcoholism or educate anyone. Punishing the disease will never cure it, hence the huge uproar and lifting of prohibition. Taxing/punishing/humiliating does nothing but drive alcoholism deeper, and does not address the cause. I truly find suspect people who applaud something like this.
Very interesting, thanks for the link
I know that it helped me to quit smoking when the cost was raised to the roof.
Drinking will be a part of insurance policies in the near future just like your smoker/non smoker status.
Fine with me ;-)
P.S. I am not saying make it illegal... tax the heck out of it so that it can help the people that are struggling with it & the friends & families that are affected.
I know that it helped me to quit smoking when the cost was raised to the roof.
Drinking will be a part of insurance policies in the near future just like your smoker/non smoker status.
Fine with me ;-)
P.S. I am not saying make it illegal... tax the heck out of it so that it can help the people that are struggling with it & the friends & families that are affected.
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
If you "tax the heck out of it" and make it prohibitively expensive people will eventually start making bathtub gin again or just switch to another (probably more dangerous) drug. Smokers and heavy drinkers are the poorest and least healthy members of society and you want to raise their taxes?:wtf2
I find it interesting people have seized on one point in this article.
Concerted positive action against the health crisis that alcohol causes is long overdue...I'm glad WHO is engaged in meaningful discussion and canvassing world wide strategies
D
Concerted positive action against the health crisis that alcohol causes is long overdue...I'm glad WHO is engaged in meaningful discussion and canvassing world wide strategies
D
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
The problem is that most of the strategies they enumerated will have the unintended consequence of harming the very people they are trying to save.
As they mention its not just about the effects on alcoholics but the effects that alcohol has on everyone/everything else.
The google earth map is very interesting, its surprising too see how bad alcoholism is in some of the small low economic countries.
NB
Forward we go...side by side-Rest In Peace
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Serene In Dixie
Posts: 36,740
Regardless of our understanding of what WHO is
planning .......it's going to be interesting to see the
effects in say.....30 years.
Let's not jump to the conclusion that it's a futile idea.
Gee....are we now peering into crystal balls?
I see positive healing ...useful information .... peer support
and hope here each day.
We can and do recover ....
planning .......it's going to be interesting to see the
effects in say.....30 years.
Let's not jump to the conclusion that it's a futile idea.
Gee....are we now peering into crystal balls?
I see positive healing ...useful information .... peer support
and hope here each day.
We can and do recover ....
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
Addiction is characterized by using despite negative consequences. Is it realistic to think that a raging alcoholic will quit to save money, or more likely that he or she will just cut the food budget? You can't punish people into changing.
Member
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 74
The road to H* is always paved with good intentions. Sin taxes have always been around, but making it prohibitively expensive will never stop alcoholics. Its a step back into social engineering and control, and back on the road to prohibition. These policies were made and considered back in the 1920's with disasterous effects. Its drove alcoholism underground. It helped to foment and establish organized crime. And it moved alcoholics to other hard drugs who might not have tried if it werent illegal.
Criminalizing behavior seems to be the only solution people can come up with and thats sad and unfortunate. I doubt these types of attitudes or thinking will change much though. Its why our jails and prisons are filled with addicts/alcoholics. Its also why the mentally ill wind up there as well. The US has more people in prison than any other country on the planet, and its exactly this type of thinking that fill them up more.
People ought to google prohibition and the period leading up to it with the exact prohibitive taxes that were placed on booze before it was made illegal. Its like the old saying, those who do not learn from history are bound to repeat it.
Criminalizing behavior seems to be the only solution people can come up with and thats sad and unfortunate. I doubt these types of attitudes or thinking will change much though. Its why our jails and prisons are filled with addicts/alcoholics. Its also why the mentally ill wind up there as well. The US has more people in prison than any other country on the planet, and its exactly this type of thinking that fill them up more.
People ought to google prohibition and the period leading up to it with the exact prohibitive taxes that were placed on booze before it was made illegal. Its like the old saying, those who do not learn from history are bound to repeat it.
Absolute Evil
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Charlotte NC
Posts: 206
If you "tax the heck out of it" and make it prohibitively expensive people will eventually start making bathtub gin again or just switch to another (probably more dangerous) drug. Smokers and heavy drinkers are the poorest and least healthy members of society and you want to raise their taxes?:wtf2
If you are poor, you should be paying your bills & buying food with what little you have, not blowing it on booze & cigs, while Medicaid takes care of your poor health.
I'm not in the best of health, either, but I work & pay for my insurance.
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
That's a false dichotomy. Just because we don't punish people financially for drinking doesn't mean we then have to foot the bill for their illnesses. There are also plenty of healthy people who buy nicotine products and alcohol. What is the point of punishing them?
Absolute Evil
Join Date: Jul 2008
Location: Charlotte NC
Posts: 206
Because there is still the risk. How healthy will those people be in 20 years?
Guest
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 46
http://content.healthaffairs.org/cgi...t/21/2/120.pdf
Member
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 65
It's ridiculous to preemptively punish people for things they might do or problems they might cause.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)