I've utilized different methods, different groups, and did my fair share of reading. I heartily agree with the sentiment that you've got to do something. Try anything and everything until you find what works for you. Keep an open mind.
My experience (and I know others have had their own, different from mine) with AA has not been a "quit for only one day" mindset. There are no rules or requirements in AA. I go to listen to people talk about how bad things were, what happened, and how they are now free. It has been helpful and inspiring.