WTBH, it's a tough decision.
Just wanted to point out that this:
Originally Posted by
wanttobehealthy 
That I should stay with what's safest which is the current higher paying job...
isn't really necessarily the absolute 'safest' route based on the recent history of non-renewal / re-signing your contract.
I'm contemplating a change because my opportunity for advancement has been lost to layoffs and elimination of positions, but kind of frozen in place based on the current job market, so not much advice or insight to offer.