Who can share at meetings?
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Ensenada, Mexico
Posts: 1
Who can share at meetings?
I could use some advice and experience about who can share at an open meeting, in terms of accumulated tradition. Apparently there is a person who has stopped attending the AA meeting I go to because she is not an alcoholic. She is an Al-Anon person, and I am given to understand she was in the habit of "preaching" to the alcoholics, and something happened - she was asked not to come or something.
Now, ostensibly, ours is an "open meeting".
What is people's experience and what is your advice about handling people who attend AA meetings but are not alcoholics themselves? Are they told in some way; is something read or included in the introductory section of meetings, or are there rules about the topics one can share about?
We were going around and around about this at the business meeting today, and we left it at "We'll do some research about AA traditions and experience, and reconsider the matter at the next meeting".
I'll be happy to consider what anyone has to say about this. Thanks in advance.
Now, ostensibly, ours is an "open meeting".
What is people's experience and what is your advice about handling people who attend AA meetings but are not alcoholics themselves? Are they told in some way; is something read or included in the introductory section of meetings, or are there rules about the topics one can share about?
We were going around and around about this at the business meeting today, and we left it at "We'll do some research about AA traditions and experience, and reconsider the matter at the next meeting".
I'll be happy to consider what anyone has to say about this. Thanks in advance.
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Leaving Sparta
Posts: 2,912
As far as I know there is nothing in the Traditions about "open meetings".
"Open meetings" are part of many group's format because it is a way for friends and families in the community to get a chance to have a better understanding of how meetings work and what AA is about. At my home group we even have a question and answers period where visitors are encouraged to ask questions.
I know that because of our Third Tradition, nobody can expel another member, regardless of how disruptive he may be, however I do not know what conditions would apply to someone who is NOT a member.
All things considered I believe that we as AA members must always remember to show a higher level of tolerance for others, even in the face of some harsh criticism
"Open meetings" are part of many group's format because it is a way for friends and families in the community to get a chance to have a better understanding of how meetings work and what AA is about. At my home group we even have a question and answers period where visitors are encouraged to ask questions.
I know that because of our Third Tradition, nobody can expel another member, regardless of how disruptive he may be, however I do not know what conditions would apply to someone who is NOT a member.
All things considered I believe that we as AA members must always remember to show a higher level of tolerance for others, even in the face of some harsh criticism
Om, Aum, Ohm...
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Punxsutawney/Pittsburgh
Posts: 4,797
A group conscience can decide that "all are welcome, but please, only alcoholics share."
At our open meeting, we give all alcoholics a chance to share, and if there's time at the end of the meeting, friends and family are asked if they have anything they'd like to add.
Peace & Love,
Sugah
At our open meeting, we give all alcoholics a chance to share, and if there's time at the end of the meeting, friends and family are asked if they have anything they'd like to add.
Peace & Love,
Sugah
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Leaving Sparta
Posts: 2,912
http://www.alcoholics-anonymous.org/...D=2&SubPage=57
A.A. Meetings
The two most common kinds of A.A. meetings are:
OPEN MEETINGS: As the term suggests, meetings of this type are open to alcoholics and their families and to anyone interested in solving a personal drinking problem or helping someone else to solve such a problem.
During the meeting there is usually a period for local A.A. announcements, and a treasurer passes the hat to defray costs of the meeting hall, literature, and incidental expenses. The meeting adjourns, often followed by informal visiting over coffee or other light refreshments.
Guests at A.A. open meetings are reminded that any opinions or interpretations they may hear are solely those of the speaker involved. All members are free to interpret the recovery program in their own terms, but none can speak for the local group or for A.A. as a whole.
CLOSED MEETINGS: These meetings are limited to alcoholics. They provide an opportunity for members to share with one another on problems related to drinking patterns and attempts to achieve stable sobriety. They also permit detailed discussion of various elements in the recovery programme.
A.A. Meetings
The two most common kinds of A.A. meetings are:
OPEN MEETINGS: As the term suggests, meetings of this type are open to alcoholics and their families and to anyone interested in solving a personal drinking problem or helping someone else to solve such a problem.
During the meeting there is usually a period for local A.A. announcements, and a treasurer passes the hat to defray costs of the meeting hall, literature, and incidental expenses. The meeting adjourns, often followed by informal visiting over coffee or other light refreshments.
Guests at A.A. open meetings are reminded that any opinions or interpretations they may hear are solely those of the speaker involved. All members are free to interpret the recovery program in their own terms, but none can speak for the local group or for A.A. as a whole.
CLOSED MEETINGS: These meetings are limited to alcoholics. They provide an opportunity for members to share with one another on problems related to drinking patterns and attempts to achieve stable sobriety. They also permit detailed discussion of various elements in the recovery programme.
Follow Directions!
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Fredericksburg, Va.
Posts: 9,730
3. The only requirement for A.A. membership is a desire to stop drinking.
That is taking it to an extreme, as Sugah says, a group conscience can decide that "all are welcome, but please, only alcoholics share."
Forum Leader
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Scottsdale, AZ, one big happy dysfunctional family!
Posts: 23,015
Originally Posted by Sugah 
A group conscience can decide that "all are welcome, but please, only alcoholics share."
At our open meeting, we give all alcoholics a chance to share, and if there's time at the end of the meeting, friends and family are asked if they have anything they'd like to add.
At our open meeting, we give all alcoholics a chance to share, and if there's time at the end of the meeting, friends and family are asked if they have anything they'd like to add.
The open meetings I attend are, well, open! We have nurses, students, etc. in attendance and it's not uncommon for Al-Anon's, addicts, codies, and gamblers to join in on our discussion groups. Speaking for myself, I appreciate hearing their experience, strength, and hope, and I know that I can trust them to respect our Traditions.
To share something funny, when we remind our members at the beginning of a meeting that non-alcoholics may be in attendance, we follow it with the thought "although we have no idea why" ;-) Lol
Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Pugetopolis
Posts: 2,384
Originally Posted by Tazman53
The third tradition only spells out who can be a member of AA, now taking that to an extreme if a non-alcoholic had a desire to not drink even if it was just for that day, they could be a member and share.
That is taking it to an extreme, as Sugah says, a group conscience can decide that "all are welcome, but please, only alcoholics share."
That is taking it to an extreme, as Sugah says, a group conscience can decide that "all are welcome, but please, only alcoholics share."
The long form of the tradition states that AA membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Only alcoholics suffer from alcoholism. However AA does not decide who is and who isn't alcoholic. Only the individual can decide for him/herself.
Personally, I am not in favor of non-alcoholics sharing in an open AA meeting. We don't have that problem in my home group, as our meeting is closed. However, an autonomous group can decide according to its own conscience who can participate.
Jim
Member
Join Date: Feb 2007
Location: Cleveland Ohio
Posts: 290
Originally Posted by jimhere
Only alcoholics suffer from alcoholism.
Like... I know what you are trying to say... but still the words just sound so wrong.
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Leaving Sparta
Posts: 2,912
Originally Posted by jimhere
The long form of the tradition states that AA membership ought to include all who suffer from alcoholism. Only alcoholics suffer from alcoholism.
Jim
Jim
Not so sure I would agree with that statement there Jim, I am sure there are many traumatized wives and children out there who suffer daily from the alcoholism. Also I thank God for the "autonomous" Tradition. I don't know how "open" an "open meeting" is if visitors are not allowed to even ask questions.What are we afraid of anyway?
Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Pugetopolis
Posts: 2,384
Perhaps I should clarify that statement. What the tradition says is that our membership ought to include alcoholics. Only alcoholics have alcoholism.
I knew that statement would raise eyebrows, but I'm not trying to stir up controversy.
As for "what are we afraid of?" What we are afraid of is that one alcoholic might not hear the AA message in an AA meeting. In the pamphlet "Problems Other Than Alcoholism," Bill tells us how the early members wanted to give membership to their non-alcoholic spouses and some of our great early friends and benefactors. It was decided that it couldn't be done because the non-alcoholics couldn't give straight AA talks nor engage in real Twelfth-Step work. If an alcoholic can't identify with other alcoholics in an AA meeting, where else could he go?
Jim
I knew that statement would raise eyebrows, but I'm not trying to stir up controversy.
As for "what are we afraid of?" What we are afraid of is that one alcoholic might not hear the AA message in an AA meeting. In the pamphlet "Problems Other Than Alcoholism," Bill tells us how the early members wanted to give membership to their non-alcoholic spouses and some of our great early friends and benefactors. It was decided that it couldn't be done because the non-alcoholics couldn't give straight AA talks nor engage in real Twelfth-Step work. If an alcoholic can't identify with other alcoholics in an AA meeting, where else could he go?
Jim
Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Green,green grass of home
Posts: 600
We cant be everything to everyone.
Only alcholics suffer from alcoholism.
Family,friends,co-workers,,etc,,etc,suffer the "effects" of anothers alcoholism.They suffer also their own disease,but not the disease of alcoholism itself.
An alcoholic needs to be with other alcoholics,to be able to share openly,have,that fellowship,with those who have---walked--this walk---for healing.
Open meetings all are welcome,but only alcoholics share,is how we do it.
Each group must decide for themselves.
My opinion...thanks!!!
Only alcholics suffer from alcoholism.
Family,friends,co-workers,,etc,,etc,suffer the "effects" of anothers alcoholism.They suffer also their own disease,but not the disease of alcoholism itself.
An alcoholic needs to be with other alcoholics,to be able to share openly,have,that fellowship,with those who have---walked--this walk---for healing.
Open meetings all are welcome,but only alcoholics share,is how we do it.
Each group must decide for themselves.
My opinion...thanks!!!
Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: anomaly
Posts: 2,180
there's the chapters..the family after and the letter to the wives.
Okay..somewhere in my thick skull...I'm guessing that was writen
for family members or al-anon, or codi.
So where do alkis draw the line..it's okay for non-alki to read the BB
and not share in an open meeting..Well the alki has to read the too..ya know.lol
So do alkis just accept things when it's convient for the alki ?
When we deem our family members don't understand us..we can just
throw the BB at them.lol
I didn't write the BB..BW did. Why did he deem it important to put those
chapters in ?
Everybody that lives with an alki suffers from alcoholism.
Gee whizz man..what kind of FX are we talking about ? Or is it just
another one of those life on life's term living with an alki.
Can an alki comprehend the amount of pain and suffering cuased by the alki.
Oh yeah..gotta read the book first inorder to work the 12 steps.
yes..yes..i know we feel depressed as heck when we're not numb out of
our freaken mind
Can an alki gain compassion after the whining stage..lol
Can a codi gain compassion for an alki..
I'm alki, i'm codi , I'm acoa.
i don't know...I got stupid drunked and high with my ex-wife.
She thought I was an alki, but she drank me under the table half of the time.lol
I hate alcoholism. Maybe there's other AA members in your group that
can relate to me and can that woman.
Just becuase i attending AA, dosn't mean i don't attend other fellowships
or church.lol Or don't read non-AA literatures.lol
I don't know..maybe the women got pionted in the right direction to
attend an al-anon meeting, where she can share freely about all
her pain and suffering without being judge and heal.
mmm..principles before personalities.
in other words ..a kettle calling a crack pot "black"
Okay..somewhere in my thick skull...I'm guessing that was writen
for family members or al-anon, or codi.
So where do alkis draw the line..it's okay for non-alki to read the BB
and not share in an open meeting..Well the alki has to read the too..ya know.lol
So do alkis just accept things when it's convient for the alki ?
When we deem our family members don't understand us..we can just
throw the BB at them.lol
I didn't write the BB..BW did. Why did he deem it important to put those
chapters in ?
Everybody that lives with an alki suffers from alcoholism.
Gee whizz man..what kind of FX are we talking about ? Or is it just
another one of those life on life's term living with an alki.
Can an alki comprehend the amount of pain and suffering cuased by the alki.
Oh yeah..gotta read the book first inorder to work the 12 steps.
yes..yes..i know we feel depressed as heck when we're not numb out of
our freaken mind
Can an alki gain compassion after the whining stage..lol
Can a codi gain compassion for an alki..
I'm alki, i'm codi , I'm acoa.
i don't know...I got stupid drunked and high with my ex-wife.
She thought I was an alki, but she drank me under the table half of the time.lol
I hate alcoholism. Maybe there's other AA members in your group that
can relate to me and can that woman.
Just becuase i attending AA, dosn't mean i don't attend other fellowships
or church.lol Or don't read non-AA literatures.lol
I don't know..maybe the women got pionted in the right direction to
attend an al-anon meeting, where she can share freely about all
her pain and suffering without being judge and heal.
mmm..principles before personalities.
in other words ..a kettle calling a crack pot "black"
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Leaving Sparta
Posts: 2,912
Originally Posted by jimhere
In the pamphlet "Problems Other Than Alcoholism," Bill tells us how the early members wanted to give membership to their non-alcoholic spouses Jim
If you want to exercise your right to autonomy and have a meeting that disallows sharing from visitors I can respect that, however we find that allowing visitors at our home group the freedom to ask questions during the open meeting works better for our community.
Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Pugetopolis
Posts: 2,384
And I too respect your right to autonomy, Peter.
I can see where giving non-alcoholic visitors the chance to ask questions could be a good thing. However, I see a difference between asking a question and sharing.
What Bill is saying in the pamphlet I referred to is non-alcoholics sharing in AA meetings can dilute the message to the still suffering alcoholic. Just sit in any open meeting where the sharing sounds more like an NA meeting (Please note that I am not slamming NA) dominates the tone of the meeting.
Jim
I can see where giving non-alcoholic visitors the chance to ask questions could be a good thing. However, I see a difference between asking a question and sharing.
What Bill is saying in the pamphlet I referred to is non-alcoholics sharing in AA meetings can dilute the message to the still suffering alcoholic. Just sit in any open meeting where the sharing sounds more like an NA meeting (Please note that I am not slamming NA) dominates the tone of the meeting.
Jim
Member
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Green,green grass of home
Posts: 600
why was al-anon started?Who is it for?The co-founders apparently[i wasnt there,,lol]saw there was a need for those,recovery programs for the ,family/friends of alcoholics.Although the family afterwards is in the BB,and,letter to the wives,Lois i believe started Al-anon,for non-alocholics.And BW,did not say hey come with us alcoholics,ya dont need your own program....
Moderator
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Leaving Sparta
Posts: 2,912
Originally Posted by jimhere
However, I see a difference between asking a question and sharing.Jim
We have always had a strong meeting format and visitors are alwys reminded that just a brief question about alcoholism and recovery is permissible.
same planet...different world
Join Date: Sep 2006
Location: Butte, America
Posts: 10,946
We also have 'open discussion' meetings.
There's also closed meetings. I attend both.
And, I admit that some of the 'open nature' sharing has been 'getting to' me lately, as well. I think any non-alcoholic should share at their al-anon meetings. Period.
Unless of course, they've been INVITED to be a speaker, they should maybe find another place for their preachments.
We occasionally have to interrupt someone who is clearly only 'sharing' because they are preaching, or have gone on too long ... it's understood that it's preferred to do so staying within the sharing baoundaries and suggestions mentioned in the preamble of the meetings. Usually it's the chair who does that job.
I'll be keeping up with this thread with interest.
There's also closed meetings. I attend both.
And, I admit that some of the 'open nature' sharing has been 'getting to' me lately, as well. I think any non-alcoholic should share at their al-anon meetings. Period.
Unless of course, they've been INVITED to be a speaker, they should maybe find another place for their preachments.
We occasionally have to interrupt someone who is clearly only 'sharing' because they are preaching, or have gone on too long ... it's understood that it's preferred to do so staying within the sharing baoundaries and suggestions mentioned in the preamble of the meetings. Usually it's the chair who does that job.
I'll be keeping up with this thread with interest.
Currently Active Users Viewing this Thread: 1 (0 members and 1 guests)
